Groups makes dubious claim of tax increase

Published: June 30, 2009

Article Tools
Font size: [A] [A] [A]
Our Social Networks
Facebook
Facebook
Sign Up newsletter

To the editor: The Harrisburg-based Commonwealth Foundation is making the dubious claim that an increase in the personal income tax will cost Pennsylvania tens of thousands of jobs ("Local Reps: Now is Not the Time," June 17, 2009).

Independent researchers have said the economic model used by the foundation should not be used for forecasting the number of jobs that will be gained or lost by a tax change. More importantly, this model explicitly and deliberately ignores the economic benefits of public sector spending, including the fact that state funds create jobs in hospitals, schools, nursing homes and road construction. The model only counts jobs its creators like, not jobs they don't.

Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz and Peter Orszag, now the director of the U.S. Office of Management and Budget, wrote during the last recession that "economic analysis suggests that tax increases would not in general be more harmful to the economy than spending reductions." A balanced approach is necessary when looking at the impact of budget cuts and tax increases. Compared to deeply cutting vital services and shifting costs to local taxpayers, a modest increase in the personal income tax rate is the least harmful choice for Pennsylvanians.

Michael Wood

Research Director

Pennsylvania Budget and Policy Center

Harrisburg

Ads by Yahoo!






Type in the characters you see in the picture below. If you have trouble reading the characters in the picture, click it to see a new one.



3 posted comments

The jobs you create with those "modest" tax increases can only be sustained in the future by raising taxes even more. How many government created jobs are managed competently.

If your going to take money out of ones persons pocket to create a job for another it would be better if it was for purchase of goods and services. Otherwise it is a zero sum gain in my opinion.

Report
Dave,  07/07/09 11:24
The jobs you create with those "modest" tax increases can only be sustained in the future by raising taxes even more. How many government created jobs are managed competently.

If your going to take money out of ones persons pocket to create a job for another it would be better if it was for purchase of goods and services. Otherwise it is a zero sum gain in my opinion.

Report
Dave,  07/07/09 11:23
thank you mr wood but i much prefer to spend my money the way i want to not the way some beauracrat thinks is right. maybe europe would be a good place for you "public sector thinkers" to practice your goofy economics. leave my money alone!
Report
jeff,  07/04/09 10:19