At mid-term, Corbett faces economic and political headwinds
HARRISBURG - Midway into his first term, Republican Gov. Tom Corbett has pursued a pro-business agenda, refusing to hike taxes or impose new levies while cutting spending for human services even as demand has increased in an anemic economy.
One key to finding more money for human services in the fiscal 2013-14 budget is reducing public pension costs, said Corbett during a Thursday meeting with The Scranton Times-Tribune editorial board at the Governor's Residence.
Corbett is scheduled to present his third budget proposal Feb. 5.
"We are looking to save money in pension reforms so we can reach out and put money in programs that have been under reduced funding in recent years," the governor said.
Potential changes to the State Employees Retirement System and Pennsylvania School Employees Retirement System include not counting overtime pay as pension earnings and adjusting how the final years of salaries are calculated, said state Budget Secretary Charles Zogby. Corbett starts the second half of his first term retaining a GOP-controlled statehouse, but Democratic inroads in the Senate could complicate Corbett priorities like selling the state-owned liquor stores and expanding school choice. Republicans control the House by a wide 111-91 margin with one vacancy, but GOP control of the Senate has narrowed to 27-23 with the Democratic pickup of three seats.
The sizeable Republican majorities last session produced the controversial state law requiring voters to show photo identification at the polls. A Commonwealth Court judge blocked implementation of the law just weeks before the Nov. 6 election and legal issues concerning it remain to be resolved.
The governor is struggling to overcome anemic poll numbers reflecting public unease with earlier education and human services cuts and his handling of the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse investigation at Penn State University while attorney general.
A recent Quinnipiac University poll gave Corbett a 40 percent job approval and 38 percent disapproval rating. This poll of 1,489 registered state voters conducted between Nov. 9 and Nov. 13 has a margin of error of plus or minus 2.5 percentage points. Corbett has signaled his intent to seek reelection in 2014, but the low poll numbers have sparked talk of a challenge to Corbett in the Republican primary from Montgomery County Commissioner Bruce Castor.
Some key areas in which Corbett has left his mark since taking office in 2011:
Human services funding
The United Way of Pennsylvania released a statewide
survey in late November indicating that state budget cuts in fiscal 2012-13 impacted 69 percent of some 800 responding nonprofits. As a result, 51 percent of respondents implemented layoffs, 38 percent reduced hours and 47 percent expanded waiting lists for services.
Corbett got legislative approval to end a state welfare program last summer that dated back to the Great Depression. The General Assistance program had provided $200 monthly payments to some 70,000 Pennsylvanians, including the disabled, domestic violence victims and people getting addiction treatments.
The governor said he wants to shift priority instead to helping thousands of individuals with mental disabilities on long-standing waiting lists for placement in group homes and other care services. He plans to propose an additional $20 million to reduce those waiting lists in the next budget.
"We are doing that (GA program) before we take care of people who can't help themselves?" Corbett asked, questioning past policies. "That's out of sync."
State aid to county-run human services programs has been cut by Corbett, continuing a long-running trend. The current budget slashed aid for human services by $84 million, or 10 percent, while a pilot project giving 20 counties flexibility to allocate the money is tested.
The cuts have led to waiting lists for individuals seeking mental health and drug and alcohol services, said Rep. Gene DiGirolamo, R-18, Bensalem, chairman of the House Human Services Committee. "I would really like to see that 10 percent cut restored," DiGirolamo said.
No issue dogged the governor more during 2012 than questions about why the state investigation of Sandusky - first under Corbett and then his appointed successor Attorney General Linda Kelly - took nearly three years. Incoming Attorney General Kathleen Kane said a top priority is investigating the pace of the Sandusky probe. Corbett said it was important to use the secrecy of a state grand jury to obtain testimony from a number of witnesses against Sandusky, and that took some time.
"Why do you use a grand jury?" he asked. "To get evidence."
The governor said Sandusky's conviction on numerous sex abuse charges proved the strategy worked.
Polls show the public remains skeptical.
A statewide poll by Franklin and Marshall College last fall found only one in six - or 17 percent - of respondents believe Corbett did an excellent or good job investigating the Sandusky case, while nearly two-thirds or - 65 percent - think he did a fair or poor job.
The poll of 632 registered state voters conducted between Sept. 18 and Sept. 23 has a margin of error of plus or minus 3.9 percentage points.
As the New Year began, Corbett dropped a bombshell by filing a federal antitrust lawsuit to block the NCAA from imposing sanctions and a $60 million fine against Penn State for its handling of the Sandusky case. He said he initially thought the sanctions were excessive but immune to challenge. He then discovered evidence that the NCAA didn't follow its own rules in imposing the sanctions.
"The stakes for Corbett in this bold strategy are immense," wrote Terry Madonna, pollster at Franklin and Marshall College and Michael Young, of Michael Young Strategic Research in their "Politically Uncorrected" column.
"In going after the sanctions and the NCAA, he is adopting a politically popular policy. At the same time, he risks the credible criticism that he is a hypocritical politician who initially supported the NCAA actions as necessary 'corrective actions,' but is now changing course because he is in political trouble."
The current state budget provides essentially flat funding for basic and higher education, a negotiated agreement made possible as state tax revenues improved last year. But public schools are still coping with the loss of almost $1 billion because of statewide cuts in fiscal 2011-12.
Corbett said the first-year cuts are a consequence of the end of federal stimulus aid, while the House Democratic Appropriations Committee said locking in those cuts meant more hikes in local school property taxes and reductions to programs and staff.
Corbett cited a new law requiring that teachers be evaluated on how well their students perform on standardized tests as one of his major achievements.
The current budget expands the amount of state tax credits available to businesses that make donations to schools for scholarships and other programs from $75 million to $100 million. Corbett has yet to win legislative approval for proposals to give scholarships to low-income students attending the worst-performing public schools and to change charter school oversight.
Corbett has pointed to creation of more than 100,000 private sector jobs - many in the natural gas industry - as a sign his business policies are working. He attributes the gain to holding the line on state tax rates while continuing to phase out the Capital Stock and Franchise Tax and enacting state laws to bring solvency to the state Unemployment Compensation Fund and limit corporate liability in some civil lawsuits. A new law exempting family farms from paying the state inheritance and realty transfer taxes means families will no longer have to sell farms to settle estates, Corbett said.
Providing a long-term state tax credit for an ethane cracker plant in Beaver County starting in 2017 offers an opportunity to re-industrialize western Pennsylvania and create a new industry sector, Corbett said.
The cuts in state aid to education and human services funding have cost public sector jobs during the past two years, said Sharon Ward, director of the Pennsylvania Budget and Policy Center, a Harrisburg think tank critical of Corbett's budget cuts.
"In the 2011-12 school year, Pennsylvania lost 20,000 jobs, more than were added through gas drilling in the Marcellus Shale since the start of 2010," she said.
Corbett's 2010 campaign pledge not to hike state taxes led to enactment early last year of the alternative he offered - the county impact fee on natural gas production to offset the impacts of drilling operations. Corbett said the impact fee puts revenue directly in the hands of local officials.
The impact fee law provides for 60 percent of revenue going to counties and local governments covered under impact fee drilling ordinances and 40 percent distributed for statewide programs. An initial $204 million in impact fee revenue was generated based on natural gas production in 2011. That amount is half what a state severance tax would have generated in revenue had it been in effect between July 2009 and December 2011, the Budget and Policy Center estimated.
"There are real questions about whether Pennsylvania's fee is enough to pay for the impacts of drilling on local communities," Ward said.
A key provision of the impact fee law remains on hold. The state Supreme Court is weighing an appeal of a Commonwealth Court ruling that struck down a provision limiting the ability of municipalities to control the location of drilling activity.
Corbett is expected to unveil his long-awaited transportation funding policy ahead of the budget address. It's been 1 1/2 years since a gubernatorial commission that he created issued a report making recommendations to generate $2.5 billion in new transportation revenue annually to fix deteriorating roads and bridges. The commission's recommendations include lifting the cap on the state oil company franchise tax. The governor said he's considering that and other recommendations in the report.
The delay in action prompted House Minority Leader Frank Dermody, D-33, Allegheny County, to suggest renaming the state Transportation Department as the "Department of Deferred Maintenance."
Corbett cut a high profile directing the quick emergency response during the devastating flooding in the Susquehanna River Basin in 2011.
The governor was less visible when a stalemate developed in the Republican-controlled state House over a recovery aid package to supplement federal disaster assistance. The Senate approved a $150 million bond issue to underwrite the state's share of aid. The House approved no-borrow bills that drew money from the Motor License Fund and other transfers.
Corbett eventually supported the House approach, but the bills weren't reconciled in the last session. Meanwhile, PennDOT shuffled money to fix washed-out roads and erect bridges, sometimes on a temporary basis, in Northeast Pennsylvania.
Corbett added $11 million this year to a state program to help financially distressed cities. The funding was added in anticipation of additional cities coming under Act 47. This was the source of a $2 million no-interest state loan last summer to the city of Scranton.
Corbett said he's making good on a campaign promise by reducing the size of the state vehicle fleet by 14 percent, with a planned 20 percent reduction by 2019. He touted the new PennWatch website offering information on state employee salaries and state contracts, increased efforts to combat welfare fraud and tighter review of applications for community development funding under the Redevelopment Assistance Capital Program among reform accomplishments.
At year's end, Corbett amended his 2011 financial interest statement to include trips worth more than $2,300 that were paid for by a Pennsylvania businessman and campaign contributor. The omission was attributed to clerical error.
That prompted Capitol activist Gene Stilp to file complaints asking the state attorney general's office and federal and county prosecutors to investigate whether the paid trips violated the executive branch's Code of Conduct.